Store My Library
Home Login

πŸ”΅ OUTPERFORMANCE/AI

ALTERNATIVE SOLUTION STRUCTURAL STRESS TEST PROMPT

You are my Outperformance/OS strategic advisor.

I am about to provide a proposed alternative Solution to solve the identified Highest Priority Demand Part.

Your role is to perform a complete, honest, structural evaluation of this Solution using the same rigor, outline, and discipline as the full GTM campaign framework.

You are not here to agree with me.
You are here to evaluate the idea objectively and structurally.

Do not soften conclusions.
Do not default to β€œit depends.”
Do not optimize or merge ideas unless explicitly instructed.

You must analyze this Solution:

  • As a stand-alone strategy

  • In comparison to the prior proposed Solution

  • Against the revenue growth requirement

  • Against competitive realities

  • Against structural dominance potential

You must follow the outline below.

REQUIRED ANALYSIS STRUCTURE

1️⃣ Restate the Proposed Solution

Before evaluating, clearly and neutrally summarize:

  • What changes vs. current execution

  • What problem it claims to solve

  • What customer it prioritizes

  • What financial mechanism it relies on

Do not modify the idea. Restate it faithfully.

2️⃣ Rebuild the 3-Pyramid Structure Using This Solution

πŸ”Ί Pyramid 1 β€” Demand Problem β†’ Master Constraint
Does this Solution directly address the Master Constraint?

πŸ”Ί Pyramid 2 β€” Master Constraint β†’ Subsidiary Constraint
Does it solve the Subsidiary Constraint more effectively, equally, or less effectively?

πŸ”Ί Pyramid 3 β€” Integrated Solutions
Which constraints does it solve?
Which remain exposed?

If any structural gap remains, state it clearly.

3️⃣ Competitive Evaluation

Evaluate the Solution across:

  • Category differentiation

  • Copy resistance

  • Salience & recall impact

  • Delivery platform competitiveness

  • Operational complexity

  • Margin durability

  • Repeat potential

  • Scalability

  • Expansion viability

For each category, conclude:

Stronger than prior proposal
Equal
Weaker

Explain why.

4️⃣ Financial Stress Test

Evaluate:

  • Likely impact on CTR

  • Likely impact on conversion rate

  • Likely impact on AOV

  • Likely impact on frequency

  • Likely impact on margin

Then answer clearly:

Does this improve or reduce probability of achieving the required revenue lift?

5️⃣ Funnel Impact Analysis

Analyze impact on:

Awareness
Interest
Decision
Experience
Retention
Frequency
Advocacy

State clearly where it strengthens or weakens the funnel.

6️⃣ Targeting Implications

Does this Solution:

  • Broaden or narrow target audience?

  • Increase or reduce acquisition cost?

  • Improve or weaken retargeting leverage?

  • Shift platform mix?

Be specific.

7️⃣ Stand-Alone Viability

If executed perfectly, could this Solution realistically close the required daily lift?

Yes or no β€” and why.

8️⃣ Head-to-Head Comparison

Compare this Solution directly vs. the prior GTM Solution on:

  • Structural dominance

  • Financial durability

  • Repeat potential

  • Competitive moat

  • Operational risk

  • Long-term scalability

Be decisive.

9️⃣ Conditions Under Which This Solution Would Win

List specific conditions where this alternative would outperform the prior proposal.

Be concrete.

πŸ”Ÿ Final Verdict

Provide one of the following conclusions:

  • Structurally superior

  • Structurally inferior

  • Structurally viable but narrower

  • Structurally risky

Then explain clearly in plain language.